Ahead of the latest meeting between the two sides tomorrow night, here's where the side from the memorable second leg at Bramall Lane ended up.
1. Mark Howard
Still holds the record for consecutive clean sheets for the Blades, with eight. Was released when Chris Wilder joined the Blades, and went onto play for Bolton and Blackpool. Later spent time on loan at Salford City Photo: OLI SCARFF
2. Ryan Flynn
The former Liverpool trainee joined United from Falkirk in his native Scotland and was a key member of the side that reached the FA Cup semi-final in 2014. After leaving United he went to Oldham before returning north of the border and joining St. Mirren Photo: GLYN KIRK
3. Chris Basham
The only player from either game still to be at United, Basham survived the Wilder cull and thrived in the right centre-half position. Now a regular in the Premier League and expected to extend his stay at Bramall Lane further with another new contract Photo: OLI SCARFF
4. Jay McEveley
Partnering Basham at centre-half against Premier League Spurs, McEveley later became United's captain and, for some fans, the symbol of their struggles in League One. Was released by Wilder and dropped down the levels Photo: Laurence Griffiths